Introduction

Receiving a severance package can feel like a lifeline after a job loss, but many employees in Ontario accept initial offers without realizing they’re entitled to far more. Employers often start with the bare minimum required by law, banking on your lack of awareness. This blog arms you with actionable strategies to negotiate a severance package that reflects your true worth under Ontario’s legal framework.

________________________________________

1. Know Your Entitlements: ESA vs. Common Law

Understanding your rights is the foundation of effective negotiation.

● ESA Minimums:

○ Termination pay: 1 week per year of service (up to 8 weeks).

○ Severance pay (if eligible): 1 week per year (up to 26 weeks) for employees with 5+ years at a company with a $2.5M+ payroll.

● Common Law: Courts award 1–24 months’ pay (or more) based on factors like age, tenure, and job prospects.

Key Insight: Common law entitlements often dwarf ESA minimums. For example, a 55-year-old executive with 20 years of service could secure 18–24 months’ pay.

________________________________________

2. Scrutinize Your Employment Contract

Your ability to negotiate hinges on the enforceability of termination clauses.

● Invalid Clauses: If the contract’s termination clause violates the ESA (e.g., excludes severance), it’s void, and you’re entitled to common law damages.

● Flexibility Clauses: Broad language allowing role changes may also undermine termination clauses.

Action Step: Have a lawyer review your contract to identify unenforceable terms that boost your leverage.

________________________________________

3. Negotiation Tips to Maximize Severance

a) Delay Signing

● Don’t rush: Employers may pressure you to sign quickly. Take time to review and consult a lawyer.

● Tactic: Respond with, “I need to consult with my advisor before I can consider this offer.”.

b) Negotiate Beyond Cash

● Extended health benefits.

● Positive reference letters.

● Outplacement services (career coaching, resume help).

● Stock options or pension contributions.

c) Highlight Employer Risks

A lawyer’s demand letter can outline risks like:

● Invalid termination clauses.

● Costly litigation if the case goes to court.

________________________________________

4. Avoid Common Pitfalls

● Accepting the First Offer: Initial proposals are rarely final.

● Ignoring Tax Implications: Lump sums are taxed higher than salary continuance (spread payments over tax years if possible).

● Overlooking Non-Monetary Terms: Restrictive clauses (e.g., non-competes) can limit future opportunities.

________________________________________

5. When Employers Refuse to Budge

If negotiations stall:

● File a Claim: Sue for wrongful dismissal within 2 years (Limitations Act).

● Ministry of Labour Complaint: For ESA violations only (e.g., unpaid wages).

________________________________________

6. The Role of a Lawyer

A lawyer can:

● Calculate your full entitlements using common law factors.

● Draft persuasive demand letters.

● Advise on tax-efficient structuring.

● Represent you in court if necessary.

Cost Tip: Many lawyers offer free consultations or work on contingency (paid only if you win).

________________________________________

FAQs

Q: How long do I have to negotiate?

A: There’s no strict deadline, but delaying beyond 2 years bars legal action.

Q: Can I negotiate if I already signed?

A: Possibly, if you signed under duress or misinformation. Consult a lawyer.

Q: What if my employer claims “financial hardship”?

A: Employers must still meet ESA minimums. Common law entitlements depend on their ability to pay.

________________________________________

Conclusion

Negotiating a severance package isn’t about “getting lucky”—it’s about knowing your rights and strategically leveraging Ontario’s employment laws. By combining legal knowledge with assertive negotiation, you can turn a standard offer into a fair settlement that supports your transition to the next chapter.

Remember: Your employer has legal counsel. You deserve the same advantage.

‍

Free Consultation with London Employment Lawyers

Ontario’s laws provide critical protections for employees during mass layoffs, ensuring they receive fair notice, severance pay, and support. If you’re affected by a group termination, understanding your rights and seeking professional advice can help you navigate this challenging time and secure the compensation you deserve. Please do not hesitate to contact our experienced London employment lawyers for a free legal consultation. Randy Ai Law Office can be contacted at (548) 489-2006 or fill out the contact form.

‍