Introduction

Imagine showing up to work only to find your role drastically altered—your salary slashed, your position downgraded, or your workplace relocated without warning. These unilateral changes can make staying in your job unbearable, effectively forcing you to resign. In Ontario, such scenarios may constitute constructive dismissal, a legal concept that protects employees from being pushed out through significant, unauthorized changes to their employment terms. This blog explores what constructive dismissal means, how to recognize it, and the steps to protect your rights.

________________________________________

What Is Constructive Dismissal?

Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer unilaterally makes fundamental changes to your employment contract without your consent, creating conditions so intolerable that you have no choice but to resign. Unlike outright termination, constructive dismissal is a "quiet firing," where the employer’s actions—not their words—force you out.

Key Elements:

1. Substantial Change: Alterations to core terms like salary, role, location, or hours.

2. Unilateral Action: Changes imposed without your agreement.

3. Intolerable Conditions: The changes make it unreasonable to continue working.

Example:

● A senior manager demoted to an entry-level role.

● A 30% pay cut without justification.

● Sudden relocation to a distant city without consultation.

________________________________________

Legal Framework in Ontario

While the Employment Standards Act (ESA) doesn’t explicitly address constructive dismissal, common law (court decisions) provides robust protections. Courts assess whether:

● The changes breached a fundamental term of the contract.

● The employee did not accept the changes (explicitly or through continued work under protest).

________________________________________

Is It Constructive Dismissal? Key Questions

1. Were the changes material and unilateral?

○ Minor adjustments (e.g., shift swaps) rarely qualify.

2. Did you object to the changes?

○ Silence or continued work under protest may still support a claim.

3. Was resignation a reasonable response?

○ Courts consider whether a reasonable person would feel compelled to quit.

________________________________________

Steps to Take If You Suspect Constructive Dismissal

1. Document Everything

○ Save emails, revised job descriptions, and pay stubs showing changes.

○ Write a timeline of events.

2. Formally Object

○ Notify your employer in writing that you do not accept the changes.

○ Example: “I am writing to formally reject the reduction in my salary effective June 1, as it breaches our employment agreement.”

3. Consult an Employment Lawyer

○ A lawyer can assess whether the changes meet the legal threshold and advise on next steps.

4. Decide: Resign or Stay?

○ Resigning: You may claim damages for wrongful dismissal.

○ Staying: Prolonged acceptance (without protest) could imply agreement.

5. File a Claim

○ Option 1: Sue for damages equivalent to reasonable notice (common law).

○ Option 2: File an ESA claim for unpaid wages if applicable.

○ Deadline: 2 years from the date of resignation (Limitations Act, 2002).

________________________________________

Employer Defenses and Risks

Employers may argue:

● Contractual Rights: The employment contract allowed changes (e.g., a flexibility clause).

● Employee Acquiescence: You agreed by continuing to work.

But: Courts scrutinize contracts closely. In Waksdale v. Swegon North America (2020), even invalid clauses voided entire termination provisions, favoring employees.

________________________________________

Remedies and Compensation

If successful, you may recover:

● Damages: Pay in lieu of reasonable notice (typically 1–24 months’ salary).

● Human Rights Awards: Additional compensation if changes were discriminatory.

● Reinstatement: Rare, but possible in unionized settings.

________________________________________

Practical Tips for Employees

● Don’t Quit Hastily: Resigning without legal advice can weaken your claim.

● Mitigate Losses: Seek new employment to reduce damages (a legal duty).

● Review Contracts: Clauses permitting role changes may affect your case.

________________________________________

FAQs

Q: Can I claim constructive dismissal if I quit?

A: Yes, if you can prove the employer’s actions forced your resignation.

Q: What if I can’t afford a lawyer?

A: Many lawyers offer free consultations or contingency fees (paid only if you win).

Q: Does constructive dismissal apply to layoffs?

A: Yes. Unauthorized layoffs exceeding ESA time limits may qualify.

________________________________________

Conclusion

Constructive dismissal is a legal safeguard against employers who try to force employees out through stealthy, detrimental changes. By understanding your rights and acting swiftly, you can challenge unfair treatment and secure the compensation you deserve.

Remember: Silence can be misconstrued as acceptance. Document, object, and seek expert advice.

‍

Free Consultation with London Employment Lawyers

Ontario’s laws provide critical protections for employees during mass layoffs, ensuring they receive fair notice, severance pay, and support. If you’re affected by a group termination, understanding your rights and seeking professional advice can help you navigate this challenging time and secure the compensation you deserve. Please do not hesitate to contact our experienced London employment lawyers for a free legal consultation. Randy Ai Law Office can be contacted at (548) 489-2006 or fill out the contact form.

‍

‍